The National Institute of Open Schooling was an instant choice. The sheer scale of operations — NIOS gave 5 lakh out-of-school students the chance to get an education in 2011-12 — ensured its selection as a winner in the government category. If NIOS was about scale, Sarvodaya Kanya Vidyalaya No.2 of Zeenat Mahal won admiration for the determination with which its turnaround was achieved. Facing shutdown at one point, this Urdu-medium school became one of the top performing government schools in Delhi.
There was unanimity among the jury that NIOS and the Sarvodaya school deserved a joint award — if one was a shining example of macro intervention, the other showed what can be achieved with micro-level efforts.
There was some debate about whether the turnaround of the Sarvodaya school, catering mostly to Muslim girls in the Walled City of Delhi, was sustainable as it seemed largely the effort of one principal. However, JM Lyngdoh pointed out it was difficult to imagine a principal could turn a school around on her own. "It's very difficult to turn around something from nothing. Others at the school also must have worked to make it possible," he added. Sunita Narain pointed out that the school was a micro effort but a very important and challenging one in a very difficult place.
In the corporate category, the jury was not impressed with the finalists and decided they would award none. They felt the claims by the corporate houses were not backed by enough evaluation of their initiatives. It sparked a debate about the need for private investment in education. Jury chairman Naresh Chandra said that from his stint as finance secretary of Rajasthan he knew states did not have the budget for school expansion, even with an educational cess. He clarified he wasn't biased against government schools as both his schooling and college education have been in government institutions. Some of the jury felt private capital ought to be used to strengthen the existing system such as improving sports facilities.
The award for NGOs went to Room to Read. The organization works with rural and urban slum communities, establishing libraries in schools and publishing original children's books in seven languages to encourage the habit of reading. They have established over 4,000 libraries in India. Syeda Hameed said the Room to Read model seemed both scaleable and practical. Aruna Roy, who was familiar with the organization's work, said it was functioning well and had helped make the concept of libraries familiar to children.
TOI Social Impact Awards: Kudos for solo work & team effort
This article
TOI Social Impact Awards: Kudos for solo work & team effort
can be opened in url
http://newsballadeer.blogspot.com/2013/01/toi-social-impact-awards-kudos-for-solo.html
TOI Social Impact Awards: Kudos for solo work & team effort
